**SC Dawn Staley Vs. LSU Kim Mulkey: Who is the G.O.A.T in Coaching?… ESPN Report Says It All**
The debate over who stands as the greatest of all time (G.O.A.T) in women’s college basketball coaching has intensified in recent years, with two names dominating the conversation: South Carolina’s Dawn Staley and LSU’s Kim Mulkey. Both have cemented their legacies as elite coaches, but the question remains—who truly deserves the title of the best? An ESPN report recently weighed in, analyzing their careers, achievements, and impacts on the game, but the discussion goes far beyond trophies and win totals.
### **Career Achievements and Championships**
When evaluating greatness, championships are often the first metric. Kim Mulkey boasts an impressive resume with four national championships—three at Baylor (2005, 2012, 2019) and one at LSU (2023). Her ability to build powerhouse programs at two different schools speaks volumes about her adaptability and coaching prowess. Mulkey’s 2012 Baylor team, led by Brittney Griner, went 40-0, marking one of the most dominant seasons in NCAA history.
Dawn Staley, meanwhile, has three national titles (2017, 2022, 2024), all with South Carolina, and has turned the Gamecocks into a perennial juggernaut. Her 2024 squad went undefeated (38-0), further solidifying her status as one of the game’s elite. Staley’s program has been a model of consistency, making multiple Final Four appearances and producing top-tier WNBA talent.
While Mulkey has one more title, Staley’s rapid rise and sustained dominance at South Carolina—a program that wasn’t historically a powerhouse—cannot be overlooked.
### **Player Development and WNBA Impact**
A coach’s legacy is also measured by the players they develop. Staley has produced a staggering number of WNBA stars, including A’ja Wilson, Aliyah Boston, and recent No. 1 pick Caitlin Clark (though Clark played for Iowa, Staley’s influence in elevating the women’s game has been undeniable). Her ability to recruit and develop generational talent has been a hallmark of her tenure.
Mulkey, too, has coached elite players like Brittney Griner, Odyssey Sims, and Angel Reese. However, critics argue that while Mulkey’s teams are successful, her system doesn’t always translate as seamlessly to the WNBA. Staley’s players, on the other hand, often excel at the professional level, suggesting her coaching style prepares athletes for long-term success.
### **Cultural Impact and Advocacy**
Beyond wins and losses, both coaches have shaped the culture of women’s basketball—but in different ways. Staley has been a vocal advocate for racial and gender equality, using her platform to push for social justice and greater visibility for women’s sports. Her leadership extends beyond basketball, making her a transformative figure in the sport.
Mulkey, while undeniably successful, has faced criticism for her resistance to certain progressive movements, including her stance on LGBTQ+ issues during Griner’s time at Baylor. Her old-school, no-nonsense approach has won games but has also sparked controversy. Staley’s ability to connect with players on and off the court gives her an edge in this category.
### **Head-to-Head Battles**
Recent matchups between Staley’s Gamecocks and Mulkey’s Tigers have added fuel to the debate. The 2023 Final Four saw LSU defeat South Carolina in a thrilling contest, but Staley got revenge in the 2024 SEC Tournament and continued her dominance in the regular season. These high-stakes clashes highlight the tactical brilliance of both coaches, with each adjusting their strategies to counter the other.
### **ESPN’s Verdict**
The ESPN report leaned slightly toward Staley, citing her ability to build a dynasty at South Carolina while also elevating the entire sport. Her combination of on-court success, player development, and cultural influence gives her a slight edge over Mulkey’s more trophy-laden but sometimes polarizing career.
### **Final Thoughts**
Determining the G.O.A.T between Dawn Staley and Kim Mulkey isn’t just about counting rings—it’s about legacy, impact, and influence. Mulkey’s four titles and success at multiple programs make her one of the best ever. But Staley’s transformative effect on South Carolina, her advocacy for women’s basketball, and her ability to produce WNBA superstars might just give her the edge.
In the end, the debate may never be settled. But one thing is certain: both coaches have forever changed the game, and women’s basketball is better for it.
