NFL free agency: Should the Steelers sign Ryan Tannehill or Mason Rudolph to rival Kenny Pickett?

As the NFL free agency period looms, the Pittsburgh Steelers find themselves facing a pivotal decision at the quarterback position. With Kenny Pickett, the talented prospect out of the draft, on their radar, the team must decide whether to stick with current roster quarterback Mason Rudolph or explore the option of bringing in seasoned veteran Ryan Tannehill to provide competition.

Mason Rudolph, a product of the Steelers’ system, has been with the team since being drafted in 2018. While he has shown flashes of potential, there are lingering questions about whether he can be the long-term solution. Some argue that Rudolph deserves the chance to compete for the starting role, given his familiarity with the team and offensive system.

On the other hand, Ryan Tannehill, with his NFL experience and proven track record, could offer the Steelers a reliable and seasoned option. Tannehill, who enjoyed success with the Tennessee Titans, brings a wealth of knowledge and leadership that could benefit the team, especially if they are in win-now mode.

The emergence of Kenny Pickett as a top quarterback prospect in the draft adds another layer to the decision-making process. The Steelers must weigh the potential of developing a rookie quarterback against the immediate impact of a more experienced signal-caller.

Ultimately, the decision between Mason Rudolph and Ryan Tannehill depends on the Steelers’ vision for the future. If they believe in the potential of a young, homegrown talent like Rudolph, they may choose continuity and development. Conversely, if the team is focused on maximizing their chances in the short term, Tannehill could be the answer.

As the NFL free agency period unfolds, Steelers fans and pundits alike will be watching closely to see which direction the team chooses to go in, and whether they opt for continuity or experience to shape the future of their quarterback position.